Collaboration Moves Utah Toward Next-Gen 911

This is an article in Emergency Management Magazine about the phone project I have been working on for the last three years and the project that I won Utah APCO’s Technician of the Year Award.

Collaboration Moves Utah Toward Next-Gen 911

When the technology in several of Utah’s 911 centers was nearing obsolescence simultaneously, three of the state’s public safety directors decided to get creative.

“We thought, why not work together?” said Tina Scarlet, executive director of the Weber County, Utah, Emergency Services District. “Why not implement a shared model that various public safety answering points could use and that would be more efficient?”

In November 2011, Scarlet and two others — former Salt Lake Valley Emergency Communications Center (VECC) Executive Director William Harry and Utah Department of Public Safety Dispatch Center Manager Chris Rueckert — submitted a request for information for a multi-node, IP-based 911 call-handling solution.

“We wanted a system with advanced call-routing capabilities that could give us greater efficiencies and ultimately cost less than our various on-premise solutions,” Scarlet said. “The upgrade to an Internet-based system would also allow us to spread 911 calls around so that no one center had to put off a call when it was too busy.”

Today, the Greater Wasatch Multi-Node Project is the first IP-capable 911 call delivery system in Utah.

Multi-Node Advantages

Once the trio decided to explore the new strategy, they compared their current vendor’s solution to alternatives offered by Intrado and CenturyLink. Both companies offered key features they desired, including an emergency service number-based ESInet for all 911 wireline and wireless call handling and routing.

“We decided on the Intrado solution because it would allow both servers to be up and operational at the same time,” said Kevin Rose, statewide interoperability coordinator for the Utah Department of Technology Services. “Redundancy was paramount.”

The IP-based Intrado VIPER call processing equipment provides quadruple redundancy at VECC and Weber County, as well as a common database for call routing and mapping systems that displays the caller’s location.

In January 2013, VECC, Weber Area 911 and the Utah Department of Public Safety/Salt Lake Communications Center went live on the new ESInet and the Greater Wasatch Multi-Node Project was officially launched.

“About that time, several of the other public safety answering points (PSAPs) became intrigued about the direction this was going,” said Mark Whetsel, technical services manager at VECC.

The original three partners realized that the new system would allow them to host much of the new technology at two centers — VECC and Weber Area Dispatch — and give other centers that got smaller upgrades access to the full system via the Internet. That would allow them to combine resources and share the cost of fully upgrading the two centers instead of spending the same amount of money on all of them, Rose said.

“As we heard of other agencies getting ready to switch out their equipment, we asked if they wanted to join. We liked the fact that it reduced costs, but it was also about the ability to back each other up,” Scarlet said. “We are all large entities, and with the capabilities of the system and the way we can have the roaming login, we felt it would be a good fit to have others join in. Before we knew it we were adding additional members.”

Today, the Greater Wasatch Multi-Node Project supports six state-level and local PSAPs covering four counties in Utah, including the Bountiful City Police Department, Greater Salt Lake Unified Police Department and Salt Lake City Police Department.

The Multi-Node Project has two servers, one in Weber County and one in Salt Lake VECC.

“The servers are synchronized images of each other connected with T1 circuits,” Whetsel said. “Because we have a major fault line that runs over half the state, we wanted to create a geo-diverse network that would enable redundancy and resiliency.”

Whetsel said that because Weber County is about 60 miles north of Salt Lake City, it was a logical place to put the second node.

“If a major earthquake should hit, the chances of both of those centers being affected simultaneously is relatively remote,” he said. “And with the multi-node system, if one server goes down, the second server can pick up without missing a beat.”

Collaboration among the partners also generates cost savings through shared resources and equipment.

“Anytime you have multiple PSAPs working together it is a huge benefit because we can share information, training, etc.,” Scarlet said.

The Multi-Node Project also enables “agent roaming,” which lets users share call-taking positions across different PSAPs during times of high-call volume.

“A 911 call taker or dispatcher can log into any shared workstation, at any location, and receive and dispatch emergency calls as if they were at their own PSAP,” Scarlet said. “This collaboration of individual PSAPs and sharing of resources is unprecedented in Utah.”


Challenges and Unknowns

Naturally, forging new ground also came with challenges.

“There were a lot of unknowns because this was the first time such a system has been done in Utah,” Scarlet said. “There was a lot of pressure to ensure it succeeded. We had a great deal of confidence in the vendors, but the pressure was there.”

Scarlet said the partners agreed early on that this was a long-term relationship and it was imperative they were all on the same page. The team put together memorandums of understanding to establish how all system components would work and formed a governance structure including representatives from each partner agency.

In all, the system took 18 months from initialization to launch. A significant portion of that time was spent establishing network facilities and formalizing contacts with vendors. The three original partners also stipulated that the new system must be cost neutral, which threw another wrench into the plan.

“We couldn’t put new equipment in and have it cost the agencies more than their current budgetary allotment for that service,” Whetsel said. “Trying to maintain cost neutrality and keeping within those fiscal boundaries with the new equipment coming in was a challenge.”

Once the system went live, with a staggered start for each partner, the new dispatcher interface took some adjustment as well.

“Trying to coordinate training was time consuming,” Whetsel said. “Because it was a new deployment in Utah, we had to work closely with support technicians on the ground. We are still trying to muddle through the governance structure. We put together a panel of representatives from all the respective agencies, and we meet at least monthly and discuss what’s going on, direction, etc. We are working on formalizing the group, but it’s still in its infancy.”


Looking Forward

In addition to its other advantages, the IP capability of the Greater Wasatch Multi-Node Project has set the foundation for other next-gen 911 data services and applications, such as text-to-911.

“We are looking to have text messaging available by May 2014,” Scarlet said. “We’re working on establishing best practices for that now. Also when someone calls 911 now, there is a database that provides coordination between the phone number and the location of the caller. It is old school and requires a lot of manipulation. So we are beginning the process of converting from that old-school way of handling the auto number and auto location to a format that is more dynamic and uses geospatial data as opposed to a flat file.”

With the goal of being better prepared for next-generation 911 within two years, Utah is also working toward a CAD-to-CAD system that would allow for the electronic exchange of information between 911 operators. Utah also hopes to expand the backbone of the new 911 system throughout the state.

“There has been some discussion about applying this model throughout the state — to other regional or shared systems, so it’s given us some different options to explore,” Rose said. “We’d like to see if this model could work in other areas of the state and look at different options for the future that could save the state money and provide us more flexibility.”

Scarlet said she’s not sure how many other PSAPs in the state might emulate the Multi-Node Project. “In terms of how many others would do combined systems, that will be up to the PSAPs,” Scarlet said. “But I have heard that other PSAPs are talking about doing something similar. Anytime you can maximize your support and interoperability, it makes sense operationally and it makes sense for the citizens.”

While the project was the first of its kind in Utah, it could help set the stage for future initiatives.

“This was definitely something new to the state of Utah, but we got a lot of support for it from the surrounding areas,” Rose said. “Because it was so new we had to do quite a bit of educating to get buy-in. It was an eye-opener, and I think it will possibly influence other types of projects in the state down the road.”

You may use or reference this story with attribution and a link to

Public Safety Agencies in Utah Team Up to Improve 9-1-1 Services

My team, Technical Services at Valley Emergency Communications Center has spent much of the last year researching, funding, planning, installing and implementing a revolutionary IP based 9-1-1 call delivery system in Utah.  Our idea was so revolutionary and groundbreaking as well as being so cost effective that several other agencies asked to join in our system with many others planning on joining in the near future.

9-1-1 call centers need to start rolling out NG 911 or Next Generation 911 by early next year as mandated by the Federal Government.  NG-9-1-1  is designed to handle text to 911 as well as video or pictures.  These features are currently not active with our new system so don’t try texting 911 just yet.  The new phone system gives us the flexibility to offer those services in the very near future.

The new phone system was a third the price of  a typical 9-1-1 call delivery system saving potentially millions of dollars in 9-1-1 funds.

The install was accomplished over a 48 hour period.  We divided our land lines and cell lines between the two system and brought up one position at a time.  It was a monstrous project completed with co-operation and hard work from VECC IT staff , VECC operations , Intrado, Vectra Solutions, and Alpine Geographic.


We were also featured in a story on KSL-5 TV

The article below was featured in 9-1-1 Magazine.

Agencies, vendors deliver the state’s first emergency services Internet protocol network (ESInet) for 9-1-1 calls

9-1-1 call centers serving Salt Lake, Davis, Weber and Morgan counties have taken the initiative to provide the first Internet protocol (IP)-capable 9-1-1 call delivery system in Utah.  Salt Lake Valley Emergency Communications Center (VECC) Executive Director, William Harry, State of Utah Department of Public Safety (DPS)/Salt Lake Communications Center (SLCC) Dispatch Center Manager, Chris Rueckert and Weber Area Dispatch 9-1-1 and Emergency Services District (Weber) Executive Director, Tina Scarlet, have led this collaboration of six individual public safety agencies to provide multiple levels of 9-1-1 network survivability—ultimately improving public safety for approximately 1.6 million citizens.

In November 2011, the team came together to submit a request for information for an IP-based, multi-node, 9-1-1 call-handling solution. They wanted to implement a “shared model” as many of the various public safety answering points’ (PSAPs) call-processing equipment (CPE) was approaching end of life and would no longer be supported.  The project, “The Greater Wasatch Multi-Node Project,” was established to find an IP-delivery system that would provide multiple levels of redundancy, advanced call-routing capabilities, greater efficiencies and ultimately less cost than their various on-premises solutions.

The plan for the Greater Wasatch Multi-Node Project was to use the VECC and Weber 9-1-1 centers to host the CPE and call-taking applications, providing access to other PSAPs via the ESInet.  This plan would allow PSAPs to pool their resources by sharing costs for two centers instead of spending funds on CPE and applications for multiple centers.

When the collaborating entities compared their current vendor’s solution to alternatives offered by Intrado and CenturyLink, they decided that the Intrado and CenturyLink platform had the IP capabilities that best met their expectations.  Intrado and CenturyLink offered an emergency service number (ESN)-based ESInet for all 9-1-1 wireline and wireless call handling and routing; IP-based Intrado VIPER® call processing equipment that provided quadruple redundancy at VECC and Weber; and a common database for call routing and mapping systems that display caller location.

Once the team made their decision, the Utah 9-1-1 Committee funded most of the project with grants.

In January of 2013, VECC, Weber Area 9-1-1, and DPS/SLCC went live on the new ESInet, surpassing expectations as the first IP-capable 9-1-1 network for the state of Utah. As a result, the Greater Wasatch Multi-Node Program has provided immediate financial benefits.  “This new shared model has already provided substantial savings on both CPE and call-trunking costs,” explained Rueckert.

As an added feature, the solution also provides “agent roaming.” In other words, the new platform can leverage advanced call-routing technology to share call-taking positions from call takers across different PSAPs during times of high-call volume.  “A 9-1-1 call taker or dispatcher can log into any shared workstation, at any location, and receive and dispatch emergency calls as if they were at their own PSAP,” said Scarlet. “This collaboration of individual PSAPs and sharing of resources is unprecedented in Utah.”

“The sharing of resources is a new frontier for all of us,” said Rueckert. “All too often, we see other state governments mandate that PSAPs collaborate and create a consolidated solution.  We took this initiative on ourselves, because it was the right thing to do.”

Other PSAPs across the state are lining up to benefit from this new shared-network solution.  The Bountiful City Police Department, Greater Salt Lake Unified Police Department and the Salt Lake City Police Department are just a few agencies that will be joining the Greater Wasatch Multi-Node Program in the very near future.  “The new ESInet platform started as a beta test for NextGen 9-1-1 and now it’s become the standard for new deployments,” said Harry.

Lastly, the IP capability of the ESInet has set the foundation for other NextGen 9-1-1 data services and applications, such as text-to-9-1-1 and media as they become more readily available. “We are confident that the benefits of this new technology will improve public safety in the near future,” acknowledged Harry.

For more information on VECC, see

– Corporate News/ (via Intrado, 3/20/13)